Land Choices: Changing Development in America
Choices for Landowners
Preserve Your Land Conservation Subdivisions Other Land Choices
About LandChoices
LandChoices' Sponsors
Land Choices in the News
LandChoices' Projects
Contribute to LandChoices
Contact Land Choices
Sites About Preserving Your Land
Activities for Children
Conservation Subdivisions

Tell A Friend About Our Site

Copyright 2007
  LandChoices -
  All Rights Reserved

From the January, 2006 issue, Traverse, Northern Michigan's Magazine

Conservation Subdivision

When people think in a dreamy way about Northern Michigan, they think of a place like Arbutus Lake, 400 acres of blue that run in a crazy, captivating spill across the landscape. The eccentric shoreline reaches to shape narrow peninsulas, arcs to etch lagoons, narrows, widens. Adding to the lake's intrigue are the high ridges that rise steeply around the shore and seem to keep the world out-a seclusion all the more remarkable considering the lake lies just 15 minutes south of Traverse City's regional-hub bustle.

No wonder people love Arbutus. And no wonder they turned out in opposition when a developer proposed to build 220 homes on an undeveloped 462-acre tract that embraces more than 3 miles of shoreline. Arbutus fans did what thousands of lake lovers have done before. They hired lawyers, they hired environmental consultants, they teamed with environmental activists to stall the project.

Eventually the developer pulled out because he was unable to reach agreement to renew the purchase option. But by then, both sides had spent a great deal of time and money, and both probably walked away thinking there must be a better way.

It's not an oxymoron, says Kirt Manecke
Kirt Manecke thinks he has that better way, not just for Arbutus Lake, but for every beautiful place in America that's slated for development. Last May, Manecke started a nonprofit company called LandChoices, based in Milford, Michigan, designed to spread the word about land preservation options. One of the most innovative and promising options he's promoting is something called the conservation subdivision-a concept he wants to borrow from conservationists and land planners and make it into a popular paradigm. Sure, conservation subdivision sounds like an oxymoron, but Manecke says it's a remarkably commonsense way to achieve the goals of key parties involved in development: the original landowner, who wants to sell but doesn't want to see his beautiful land scraped clear for sod; the homeowner, who wants to live in a parklike setting and have a home that appreciates well; the developer, who wants timely approval of his project and a profitable outcome; and the community, which wants to preserve the rural character.

A conservation subdivision begins with a careful assessment of the land. "Before ever selling to a developer, the landowner walks the land with a preservation specialist and marks off all the special places that the owner would like to see preserved," Manecke says. Those areas are off limits to development.

The property is then evaluated for home placement, with sites selected that respect the land and provide views for the homeowner. Next, roads and hiking trails are planned. "Roads have homes on one side only, so everybody has a view of open space across the street," he says. And finally the developer draws the lot lines. "It's completely opposite traditional subdivision design," Manecke says.

Conservation subdivision typically preserve 50 to 70 percent of the land. "Developers say, 'I'll make less money because there will be fewer lots,'" Manecke says. "But that's not the case."

Conservation subdivisions typically preserve 50 to 70 percent of the land
The lot sizes are smaller-but the number is the same, and the value is often higher because of the richness of the parklike setting. "The real estate market has proven, with lots along lakefront and golf courses, that small lots can actually appreciate faster," he says.

Learn more about LandChoices at

A conservation agreement on the undeveloped land assures the homebuyer that the open space will remain open space. One of the biggest hurdles Manecke hopes his new nonprofit can overcome is traditional zoning that all but mandates cookie-cutter subdivisions and doesn't respect the land's natural features. "We need to convince zoning boards that conservation designs must be the norm, and you need a variance to do anything but this," Manecke says.

For anybody who loves the look of their Northern Michigan community, those are wise words to heed. Just ask the fans of Arbutus Lake. The 462-acre parcel is now for sale on Ebay, listed for $10.5 million. Just click on "see all land parcels," sort by "Price: highest first," and there it is, right on top-its future open to speculation.

Jeff Smith is editor of Traverse.

Land Choices

only search LandChoices
Preserve Your LandConservation Subdivisions | Other Choices

Home | About Us | News | Projects | Sponsors | Contribute | Contact Us | Links | Kids | Media Kit

 LandChoices • P.O. Box 181 • Milford, MI 48381 •